The vast majority of the time, 1 and 1
openings show hands with a real club or diamond suit. Normally we open with one of our longest suit (or 1NT with the appropriate strength and distribution). The only time a problem occurs is when our longest suit is a 4-card major, and
we have the wrong strength to open 1NT.
That means there are only four possible problem distributions:
In Standard American, hands 1, 2, and 3 are opened 1, and hand 4 is opened 1
. (Always open 1
with 3-3 in the minors.) This style is often called "convenient minor." Some partnerships agree instead to open "better minor" and open hand 1 with 1
. Others agree to play a "short club" open all four of these hands with 1
.
Outside of North America, bidding a 3-card suit is commonly called a prepared minor opening, because this bid is made in preparation for a easy rebid:
Now, let's go across to the other side of the table, and see whether we need to worry about partner having his suit or not:
If partner rebids his suit, he normally has at least six cards. 1-1
-2
and 1
-1
-2
absolutely promise six cards. 1
-1
-2
could be a strong 5-card suit. If opener has a minimum 3-1-4-5 or 3-4-1-5, he has to choose between raising spades with three or rebidding clubs with five.
If partner bids a second suit at the 2-level, his first suit is always real, and almost always 5+ cards long. 1-1
-2
almost guarantees five diamonds and four clubs. 1
-1
-2
might be a 1-4-4-4 hand.
Opener's reverse shows extra strength, and promises his first suit is longer than his second. -1
-2
is a better opening bid than 1
. 1
-1
-2
promises 5 clubs and 4 diamonds: he would raise hearts or bid spades with a 4-card major, and again, 2-3-4-4 or 3-2-4-4 hands would bid 1NT (and might open 1
).
If opener bids one minor and raises the other, he really has both of them. His raise promises 4-card support, and with you'd never open a 3-card minor if you had 4 of the other. If the bidding goes 1-2
-3
, opener has at least four of each. After 1
-1
-2
, opener likely has 5 clubs and 4 diamonds: a balanced hand might have bid notrump.
If opener raises responder's major, you'll be playing in responder's major suit. After 1-1
-2
, opener may or may not have a club suit, but it doesn't matter, since the final contract will never be in clubs. (A 3
bid by responder now would ask opener to choose between partscore and game in spades according to how good his clubs are -- it's not an offer play in clubs.)
If opener rebids NT and responder has a balanced hand, you'll be playing in NT. If responder has KJ86
AQ6
K832
J8 and the auction goes 1
-1
-1NT-3NT, opener might be 3-4-3-3 or 2-3-3-5, but you'd want to be in 3NT either way.
You should still usually assume opener has a real suit unless he tells you otherwise. For instance, suppose you hold KQ965
K73
2
J752. Partner opens 1
, you respond 1
, partner rebids 1NT. Your next bid should be 2
whether opener has a real club suit or not. Opener will choose between clubs and spades - and if he opened a 3-card club suit, he has to have at least three spades, and will now bid 2
.
The one "dangerous" auction, 1-2
/ 1
-2
, is rare. Responder will only raise opener to two if he doesn't have a 4-card major and he has an unbalanced hand and isn't willing to bid 1NT -- this means reponder almost always has 5-card support for this raise.
In summary, if opener